The contents of each Lucky Fortune Cookie is a complete surprise, whether they are sold individually or as a pack. And with 100 charms to collect & a random distribution within the different rarity levels, there’s a good chance you will get a different charm every time you open one, the color of the cookie does not affect the contents. That said, there’s still a small chance you could get the same charm more than once. You can always save your cookie, charm and fortune and trade with a friend who has been hoping to get that particular charm.
Please refer to the collector's sheet and note the color of the diamond adjacent to the charm to determine the rarity of your charms!